The Taxation Committee is considering two competing tax-reform plans – one that would lower the income tax to a flat 6 percent and another that would drop that rate to a flat 4.9 percent by adding a penny to the sales tax.
Both plans raise money for the income tax reduction by making more goods and services subject to the sales tax and by increasing the meals and lodging tax from 7 to 8 or 8.5 percent, and taxing beer, wine, soda and snack food at 8 percent. The meals and lodging rate is still being negotiated.
“We could send both upstairs,” said Committee Chairman Rep. John Piotti, D-Unity, who said the real decision could come down to which one is more politically palatable.
The committee has been working on its tax-reform proposal for months. The goal is to replace the state’s graduated income-tax system with a flat tax and bring down Maine’s top income-tax rate of 8.5 percent. That high rate kicks in at a low level – $18,250 of taxable income for individuals – and adds to Maine’s reputation as one of the most overtaxed state’s in the county.
Both plans are based on making more goods and services, from haircuts to plumbing repairs, subject to the state’s sales tax, currently at 5 percent. The bolder plan would raise that rate to 6 percent.
The plans are based on the same logic, said Rep. Dick Woodbury, an independent from Yarmouth, who is pushing the bolder version. He believes the lower income tax would help attract more businesses to the state.
“The difference being the penny or not the penny and the 6 percent rate versus the 4.9,” he said.
Rep. Thomas Watson, D-Bath, said his concern is which one could get passed. “We’ve got to get this package out of the House and out of the Senate,” Watson said. “We’re going to take the accusation fairly that we’re raising taxes,” just by broadening the sales-tax base, he said. “If we go one step further and add a penny, we’re clearly raising taxes.”
Maine Revenue Services estimates the plans, respectively, save Mainers anywhere from $177 million to $235 million because a portion of the sales tax is “exportable,” meaning it is paid by out-of-state visitors. Those exported sales taxes would then pay for an income-tax cut for residents.
Expanding the sales-tax base, however, could be a hard sell as interest groups, who don’t want to see their industry or business taxed, start lobbying against the proposal.
Maine has a high number of exemptions currently on the books. Those businesses that could see their exemptions removed include personal care services like haircuts, pedicures, manicures and health club memberships. A long list of other services, including dry cleaning, house painting, electrical and plumbing work and snowplowing also would be subject to the sales tax, as would lawn care and chimney cleaning.
Amusements, entertainment and recreational services – from movie and ski lift tickets to golf course fees – would be in, as well as newspapers and magazines. Funeral services have been taken off the proposed list, but caskets are still included.
The lobbying has been somewhat subdued so far because the plan has been in the discussion stage for so long. It picked up steam when the Maine Realtors Association started running ads denouncing the committee’s plan to eliminate the mortgage deduction on state income taxes as part of the proposal.
The plan does eliminate standard and itemized deductions, but then creates a choice for taxpayers between a refundable tax credit or 12 percent of their federal itemized deductions.
Mike Allen, the chief forecaster for the Maine Revenue Service, said, “the average household should actually see a bigger benefit.”
The proposal to decrease the income-tax rate to 6 percent by expanding the sales-tax base appeared to have the most support Monday among committee members, although the 4.9 percent plan was picking up steam.
Sen. Ethan Strimling, D-Cumberland, said he supports the penny hike on the sales tax, but wants the relief it buys to be more equitably distributed among lower-income tax payers. While the flat income-tax rate would be made more progressive with tax credits, the lower the rate goes the more it favors those residents who pay the most in income taxes.
“I don’t believe in trickle-down economics,” Strimling said.
Rep. Scott Lansley, R-Sabattus, picked up on Woodbury’s theme that the lower income-tax rate would attract more business here because it would make the state more attractive to higher-paid professionals.
“If the CEO moves here, the company’s going to move here,” Lansley said. “Aren’t we trying to attract more business? Aren’t we trying to keep our young people here?”
The committee was expected to continue its discussion through most of this week.
Comments are no longer available on this story