State tourist officials defended their new Internet advertising campaign last week against charges it is diverting Web traffic away from local chamber sites, saying the program will benefit more businesses in Maine and help boost flagging visitor numbers.
Since last July the state has been outbidding competitors for prime positions on search engines like Google when potential visitors to the state type in a dozen or so keywords.
The problem is those keywords include some popular destinations, like Portland, Bar Harbor, Bangor, Camden and Freeport. The owner of a web development and marketing firm in Searsmont said the state is actually diverting traffic from the Camden-Rockport-Linconville Chamber and bidding so high it was making it impossible for locals to compete.
Lance Dutson of Maine Coast Design went so far as to write about his concerns on his blog and started complaining in that space about what he felt was slow response from the state tourism officials.
Last Friday, state tourism officials and some of their contractors hosted a meeting to explain themselves. While Dutson didn’t stick around for the answers, others who stayed for the nearly two-and-half-hour meeting said the state is on the right track.
Reaching out
The new campaign is called pay-per-click advertising, where organizations or companies trying to get noticed bid for top billing when an Internet user punches in a key word or phrase. In one example given at the meeting, the state bid $1.25 per click for a town keyword, while a local advertiser was only able to bid 80 cents.
The state, it was argued, is essentially using taxpayer money to outbid the locals.
Justin Davis, of Portland Webworks, who has a contract with the Maine Office of Tourism, agreed the state bids higher, but not an unreasonable amount in the pay-per-click advertising world.
National advertisers would pay as much for the same spot, he said, but the state site can stay on top because it also attracts more visitors – something else search engines like Google take into account when awarding positions.
The price to taxpayers is also not as high as the bid, in most cases, with the average cost per click on all the words the state has bid on in the last eight months coming in at 50 cents. So far the total cost of the pay-per-click program, which started last July, has been $31,599 for 62,662 clicks. The state only pays for the ad when somebody clicks on it and opens up the site.
Whether that money is well spent depends on your perspective.
The actual number of times the Maine Office of Tourism Web site – VisitMaine.com – popped up as an option as a result of the key words it bids on was 1,667,064, but people only clicked on it, on average, 3.8 percent of the time.
That number has improved to 7 or 8 percent in the last three months and has been growing since the program was introduced.
But true success of the pay-per-click program is measured in the number of conversions or the number of people who click and then use the Maine Office of Tourism site to request more information or e-mail a specific business. The percentage of those that actually ask for more information about a Maine vacation has been in the 4 to 5 percent range in the last three months.
And, when you divide the number of people who actually wanted more information into the cost of the ad, the numbers get pretty steep.
The cost of converting a person who clicked on Portland, Maine was $6.40; Bar Harbor, $2.66; Bangor, $10.72; Camden, $24.05; Acadia National Park, $22.98; Ogunquit, $20.48; and, Freeport, $22.50. More general terms like Maine vacation cost $14.77; Maine travel, $10; Maine lighthouse, $7.72; and, Maine antique, $9.94.
What money buys
The Maine Office of Tourism has an annual budget of $7.5 million, and an estimated $3.5 million of that is spent on advertising.
Tom McCartin of the state’s tourism ad agency, Warren Kremer Paino, estimated “a couple hundred thousand” of that is spent on Web advertising, of which the pay-per-click campaign is just a part.
Yet pay-per-click generates some of the most qualified leads, according to the tourism department, with the average web visitor spending nine minutes on the site.
State Rep. Stephen Bowen, R-Rockport, who had helped organize the meeting on Dutson’s behalf, wanted to know what the Maine Office of Tourism website did for businesses in his district.
“Is this helping my Camden, Maine, businesses?” he asked.
Bowen also wanted to know why the Maine tourism site couldn’t automatically link visitors to local chamber sites instead of a town page created by the state.
“It seems like you’re outbidding your own chamber,” Bowen said, so why not direct traffic immediately back to them?
According to Davis of Portland Webworks, 3,500 businesses are linked from the site, and the state wants to represent all businesses, not just ones that are members of chambers.
Aaron Perkins, general manager of The Dunes in Ogunquit, said the VisitMaine.com site was one of the top three drivers of people to his business, along with Web sites maintained by the Innkeepers Association and his local chamber. He said the more places he appears on the Web the better.
And, local businesses or chambers still have a shot at appearing in the top 10 list of sites on Google even if their bid is lower than the state’s.
“It’s like seeing a 10-column ad in the New York Times and saying, ‘I can’t have it,'” said Perkins. “They have the whole rest of the page to buy.”
At the end of the hearing, Bowen said the state had done a good job making its case.
“You guys have convinced me this is the right way to go,” Bowen said, in terms of getting the state’s tourism Web site in front of as many eyes as possible. But, he advised, “obviously a little bit of damage control needs to be done quickly.”
Comments are no longer available on this story