A group of Scarborough parents are planning on bringing their complaints regarding the issue to the school board at its Thursday, Oct. 6, meeting at 7:30 p.m. at Town Hall.
A Scarborough father has become so upset at the recent changes to the town’s school bus stops that he has followed his child’s bus to Pleasant Hill School three times and has become a self-styled “volunteer parent bus monitor,” leading the school district to threaten legal action against him.
Erwin Rupert of Old Neck Road wants to have his bus stop moved from the Old Neck Road/Melbourne Road intersection 200 yards to the east in front of his house during the afternoon stop when his child is the only one dropped off.
Through his child he learned that the bus was stopping at other homes along the route. To verify this Rupert followed the bus on three different occasions and on Sept. 15 was stopped and questioned by Scarborough police.
He has since filed a complaint against school district Business Manager Herb Hopkins because Rupert felt Hopkins broke school policy regarding contacting law enforcement.
He said Hopkins inappropriately authorized a school bus driver to contact the police on the basis of suspicious about Rupert’s actions. He said the school policy dictates staff may contact police if they feel there is a threat to the welfare and safety of the schools, students or staff.
The first time Rupert followed the bus he discovered it stopped in front of four homes. After notifying the district he was told the practice would stop, but it continued, he said.
Eventually Rupert checked the school board minutes to learn more about the issue and learned that the reason for the new stops was to increase cost savings and route efficiency. He also found a set of minutes that indicated that parents would have to monitor bus stops because many of the new ones would be out of their sight.
“This motivated me to become what I called a self-styled parent bus safety monitor,” he said. “I agree that parents do have to monitor now because it’s unsafe.”
He met with Superintendent Bill Michaud and Hopkins Tuesday to discuss his complaint and was told not to follow the school buses. If he did, he said he was told the district would request a protection from harassment order to force him to stop.
Rupert said he promised to stop his bus monitoring pending the safety committee’s decision. He also volunteered to meet with the police or school personnel to discuss the role of bus monitor and said he would obey all laws while pursuing the change in the district’s school bus policy.
“Parents get passionate about their kids,” Rupert said. “Cars and highways are the most dangerous things for our children.”
Rupert met with the safety committee, a group who considers bus stop changes, on Wednesday and asked the stop be moved.
He explained that in the morning there is one other child at the stop and Rupert is able to walk his child to the bus stop.
But in the afternoon his child may have to walk home alone. He is concerned that his child may be in danger because there is a glare on the road, no sidewalk and visibility issues. It also is a busy road, as the only entrance for the Ocean View neighborhood. The bus had stopped in front of his house for seven years.
Not alone
Rupert is one of many parents who are upset over the Scarborough school district’s newly instituted bus route policy. A group of parents are planning on bringing their complaints regarding the issue to the Scarborough school board at its Oct. 6 meeting to see if the policy can be changed.
“I want them to explain why they think all of a sudden these children are safe and don’t need to be picked up at their door, at least the little ones,” said Maureen Verreault, a Summerfield Lane resident who would like to bus to travel down her road.
As in many other Scarborough neighborhoods, the bus had traveled down Verreault’s road in the past. But this fall the district consolidated its bus stops to save money and reduce the duration of students’ bus rides, and now many students must walk to their bus stops.
This fall the district instituted a new bus policy requiring children in grades K to 5 to walk up to a quarter-mile to the bus stop and children in grades 6 to 12 walk up to a half-mile to a bus stop.
The safety committee was formed as part of the new policy. It only has the authority to review the bus stops based on safety issues and not parental convenience. It has met on two occasions and has changed a few stops.
The new policy is designed to consolidate bus stops and create centralized locations, which will save the district time and money. Hopkins said the change allowed the district to hire two fewer bus drivers this year and also is saving money in fuel. He estimates the district has saved between $80,000 and $85,000 in salaries, benefits and lower fuel usage.
Hopkins said the complaints are coming in less often and thought Wednesday might be the last time the safety committee has to meet.
“I can’t say I’m getting a lot of new calls,” he said.
Many of the complaints have come from people living in subdivisions who feel the stops are unsafe primarily for traffic reasons. But the committee has felt differently.
“We just don’t see that as being a safety issue,” Hopkins said about the traffic in some subdivisions, which primarily local. “Safety is thrown at us, but the underlying reason is probably something else.”
At this point there has not been any school board discussion on the issue nor is there any indication that it is interested in changing the policy, according to Superintendent Bill Michaud.
School board Chairman David Beneman said he does not think the new policy is controversial and has heard very few complaints.
“If there’s something that needs to be addressed, we’ll address it,” Beneman said. “You have to balance safety and efficiency and see how that works out.”
Parents are worried about the changes for a number of reasons. Some say they are worried about their child’s safety during the winter, when snow banks narrow the streets and create less visibility. Others feel there is too much traffic in their neighborhood. The board also has received concerns from parents about neighbors.
Tamara Murray, who lives on Littlefield Lane, said the bus drives past her home and then stops on Maple Avenue a couple of houses away. While the walk is short, she is worried about the winter.
Murray said she has not met with the safety committee because she walks her child to the stop and will probably drive her child to school or to the bus stop during the winter.
Michelle Lawson is planning on attending the upcoming board meeting after the safety committee did not relocated her child’s bus stop on Beech Ridge Road.
Lawson lives on Berry Road and her child must walk up the narrow road and cross Beech Ridge Road to meet the bus. The bus traveled down Berry Road in the past. Lawson is concerned about her child walking up the road. She also said that there are no other children at the stop and no homes nearby.
“It appears now that where things stand, they are not going to budge,” she said, adding that she would be willing to pay $1 a week to have the bus come down the road. “I think it’s all about money, I honestly do.”
Other parents who were interviewed declined to comment and did not want to have their names mentioned because they were happy with their stops, some of which are in front of their homes.
Comments are no longer available on this story