3 min read

As Mainers prepare to celebrate Labor Day next Monday, the average wage is up and so is the number of people employed. Defying logic, the unemployment rate also has risen as the number of people looking for work outpaces the number of new jobs that have been created.

Those that watch the labor market are breathing a big sigh of relief for what isn’t happening – the loss of 2,771 civilian jobs held by Maine residents working at the Portsmouth Naval Shipyard. The Base Realignment and Closure Commission last week voted to keep the yard open, but close the Brunswick Naval Shipyard, which has more military personnel than civilian workers.

If the yard had closed, unemployment in Maine towns within a 30-mile radius of Kittery would have spiked from 3.9 percent to 7.7. With average pay levels of $62,852 annually – or nearly twice the average in the region – that would have meant a loss of close to $188 million in direct civilian wages spent here, according to a Department of Labor report prepared earlier this summer.

Statewide, the average wage is $31,897 and seasonally adjusted unemployment was 5 percent in July.

Closing the Shipyard would have further eroded union membership in the state as it prepared to mark the holiday started by the labor movement. Maine already has lost union members as paper mills have closed or downsized and the other big union powerhouse – Bath Iron Works – has laid off workers. In 2004, the last full year of statistics available, 11.3 percent of those employed in Maine were union members down from 14 percent in 2000, according to the labor department.

In the last 10 years, from 1994 to 2004, 20,000 manufacturing jobs have been lost, driven by cuts at the mills. Paper mills accounted for 5,000 lost jobs; leather goods like shoes – 6,800; and, textiles, 4,400.

Advertisement

Paper mills were stable employers until the late 1990s and had been for 40 years, according to Glenn Mills, a senior analyst at the labor department. And, they also paid the most as compared to textile and leather manufacturing jobs.

Many of the jobs lost in manufacturing, like the shoe shops and textile mills, “never paid much,” Mills said, nor were they heavily unionized.

There is no single sector driving Maine’s emerging economy, which has gained 82,300 jobs from 1994 to 2004, but health care coupled with social services leads the pack.

In the last 10 years, the most jobs have been created in the following areas:

health care/social assistance – 28,000

retail trade – 12,400

Advertisement

professional business service – 10,900

government – 10,800

leisure and hospitality – 10,300

construction – 9,900

The fact the state has added jobs but seen its seasonally adjusted unemployment rate go up is a function of more people looking for work. Year-over-year in July, 3,700 jobs were created but the unemployment rate went from 4.5 percent to 5 percent.

Dana Evans, the state labor economist, said it’s not clear yet what’s happening, but it is likely a combination of things.

The state has seen a population increase of 8,000 in the first four years of the decade and some young people, who were already here, reached working age. Simply stated, Evans said, the increase in the labor force is exceeding the number of new jobs available.

Comments are no longer available on this story